PDA

View Full Version : LBPC Mafia: GAME OVER



Ryan86me
01-08-2014, 10:01 PM
http://i.imgur.com/lJlpVnm.jpg

LET THE GAME BEGIN. The night will commence either after all votes come in or on Friday, January 10th at 6:00 PM.

There are two individual teams – the North and The South. The game proceeds in two repeating stages – day and night – and starts off with day.

Every day, each member of the game will use logical deduction and exquisitely random guessing to try and determine who they would like to vote for – the North elves wanting to discover who is Southern and vote them off, and the Southern elves voting on whoever floats their boat, as whoever gets the most votes dies. There shall be NO PMs among North elves – all discussion will remain on the game’s thread. Everybody will vote on whoever they would like to die. The handsome host of the game – yours truly – will frequently tally up these votes, in order to give the North Elves and the South Elves a report, which will be publicly posted as a standard, grade-A post.

When the night comes, the South will privately communicate over a private chat who they would like to assassinate. Then, when they come to a conclusion, they will all PM me the group’s choice.
If the North Elves manage to kill off all of the South Elves, they will have officially won the game. If, however, at any time, the number of South Elves is greater than the number of North Elves, the South Elves will have won the game.
When playing this game, there are two things you will largely want to do. First, you will want to tell off all of those Southern scumbags, and find out who they are. This requires deep, hard thinking, but guessing or using Random.org is, of course, a perfectly viable solution. The second thing you want to do is profess your innocence, though you will probably save this for when you have a lot of people screaming “ER MEH GEHRD HE’S SOUTHERN LET’S VOTE ON HIM YEAAAAAAAAAAAA”.

TURNS

The game will start in the day. During the day, all players will vote on who they would like to kill (South Elves included). After all of the votes come in, or the 2 real-life day limit comes and ends the day, the night will start.
During the night, the South Elves will discuss, via a private chat, who they want to kill. They will have one real life day to do so. Nobody can post anything related to the game at this time (all game-related discussion will happen during the day). After I receive confirmation from the South Elves and PM's from the special North Elf roles, or the 1 real-life day limit comes and ends the night, the day will come, and I will provide a report that will say what happened during the night.

Should a player not post for 3 in-game days (nights not included) in a row, they will automatically be killed. This ensures that everybody on the thread is active, and helps with the pacing.

Remember

- Do not privately tell anybody else of your role. You can say your role all you want in the actual thread, but there's no way to prove that you're not lying, so it really won't mean a grain of salt.
- North Elves cannot PM each other about the game under any circumstance, but the South Elves can PM each other (only each other, however – NOT North Elves)
- No posts related to the game may be made in the in-game night. Discussion is allowed, but it cannot be related to the game.
-If you are confused when it comes to the rules of this game, go check out Burnvictim's LBPC Mafia thread to see the game in action.http://i.imgur.com/h7g8BX2.png-flamingemu: LIVING
-RockSauron: LIVING
-Shooter0898: LIVING
-amoney1999: LIVING
-FreeAim: LIVING
-Ali_Star: LIVING
-CogMonkey: DEAD (Elfy)
-DawnBreaker_23: LIVING
-SnipySev: DEAD (Elfy)
-gdn001: LIVING
-jarreguin001: LIVING
-butter-kicker: LIVING

RockSauron
01-08-2014, 10:04 PM
So... who here is brave enough to take up the first move?

Shooter0898
01-08-2014, 10:20 PM
So... who here is brave enough to take up the first move?

*Makes up random suspicion based on the comment*

Nah I'm kidding. But I don't like making this call so I abstain.

DawnBreaker_23
01-09-2014, 12:03 AM
From past experience I know that all of you will automatically bandwagon on the one who speaks up first, soooooo..... I'll be the dummy who does the first accusation. I say Mr. Shooter is a Elfo. Stupid, I know (gotta get that ball rolling) but he abstaine. Like really? Grow some balls and take action! (Always wanted to say that, btw. Sorry Shooter) Another not so good reason is because it's Shooter, and he's mean. .-.
I'm not voting Shooter just want to get the small snowball rolling.

ARD
01-09-2014, 12:17 AM
I vote for RockSauron, obviously :)

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 12:20 AM
I vote for RockSauron, obviously :)

I return the vote for Ard because it is obvious he is only in this to kill me off, which I do not want for obvious reasons.

Dragonvarsity
01-09-2014, 01:08 AM
HOORAY FOR EXECUTIONS!

http://media.animevice.com/uploads/0/69/645308-anime_gifs_4.gif

I can't wait to see how this day turns out.

FreeAim
01-09-2014, 06:26 AM
Like really? Grow some balls and take action!
I'm not voting Shooter just want to get the small snowball rolling.
Well, one can not exactly argue with this. "Guys, get the ball rolling (if you have some yourselves), but don't include me in it because I don't want to look suspicious."

Right now, I can't vote for anyone, but I will before the first day ends. I swear.

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 10:42 AM
Well, obviously she wouldn't tell herself to grow balls. She's a girl. >_>

ConverseFox
01-09-2014, 10:51 AM
Well, obviously she wouldn't tell herself to grow balls. She's a girl. >_>

http://i44.tinypic.com/2z9m845.png

FreeAim
01-09-2014, 11:49 AM
Well, obviously she wouldn't tell herself to grow balls. She's a girl. >_>

Steroids.

gdn001
01-09-2014, 12:50 PM
GIFs and awkward off-topicness? The game has officially begun! 8)

Ali_Star
01-09-2014, 02:37 PM
So... who here is brave enough to take up the first move?

Well since you were the first one to post, i'm guessing..... you?

Very suspicious. VERY FLIPPING SUSPICIOUS INDEED.

VOTE RAWK

Nah wait... maybe I'm being a bit giddy. It's been a while since we played and I'm getting over excited.

UNVOTE RAWK

But seriously, here's who I think potentially may be mafia:

-flamingemu
-RockSauron
-Shooter0898
-amoney1999
-FreeAim
-CogMonkey
-DawnBreaker_23
-SnipySev
-gdn001
-jarreguin001
-butter-kicker

I'm on to you guys!

http://cdn.themetapicture.com/media/funny-gif-Simpsons-dog-eyes-suspicious.gif

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 03:07 PM
Well since you were the first one to post, i'm guessing..... you?

Very suspicious. VERY FLIPPING SUSPICIOUS INDEED.

VOTE RAWK

Nah wait... maybe I'm being a bit giddy. It's been a while since we played and I'm getting over excited.

UNVOTE RAWK

But seriously, here's who I think potentially may be mafia:

-flamingemu
-RockSauron
-Shooter0898
-amoney1999
-FreeAim
-CogMonkey
-DawnBreaker_23
-SnipySev
-gdn001
-jarreguin001
-butter-kicker

I'm on to you guys!

http://cdn.themetapicture.com/media/funny-gif-Simpsons-dog-eyes-suspicious.gif

Not counting yourself as a potential mafia?

SUSPICIOUS!

I would vote for you, but unfortunately I am locked in a never ending force of wills with Ard.

Ali_Star
01-09-2014, 03:18 PM
Who the heck is Ard? :confused:

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 03:21 PM
Who the heck is Ard? :confused:

... See what you do, Ard? NOW NO ONE REMEMBER YOUR TRUE NAME!

Anyway, not to get back on track or anything, but... can we get back on track?

Ali_Star
01-09-2014, 03:34 PM
... See what you do, Ard? NOW NO ONE REMEMBER YOUR TRUE NAME!

Anyway, not to get back on track or anything, but... can we get back on track?

Yes, lets.

So...... are you mafia?

DawnBreaker_23
01-09-2014, 04:59 PM
Ard is CogMonkey. I think

Shooter0898
01-09-2014, 05:19 PM
This all so very confusing.

Oh and :gopher:

FreeAim
01-09-2014, 06:57 PM
Ssh, guys, I am waiting in the bushes. Can somebody make a list of people who haven't posted anything yet?

Nevermind, I'll do it myself: (the ones italized and turned gray have said something and also the list is copy from the main post because I am lazy)

-flamingemu: LIVING
-RockSauron: LIVING
-Shooter0898: LIVING
-amoney1999: LIVING
-FreeAim: LIVING
-Ali_Star: LIVING
-CogMonkey: LIVING
-DawnBreaker_23: LIVING
-SnipySev: LIVING
-gdn001: LIVING
-jarreguin001: LIVING
-butter-kicker: LIVING

I will update the list as more people show up. Even if you are going to be like, inactive here for one reason or another, it would be reassuring to get a confirmation for such a thing as it is still early in the game. (I know it's in the first 24 hours and not all people have seen this yet.)

butter-kicker
01-09-2014, 07:08 PM
Ssh, guys, I am waiting in the bushes. Can somebody make a list of people who haven't posted anything yet?

Nevermind, I'll do it myself: (the ones italized and turned gray have said something and also the list is copy from the main post because I am lazy)

-flamingemu: LIVING
-RockSauron: LIVING
-Shooter0898: LIVING
-amoney1999: LIVING
-FreeAim: LIVING
-Ali_Star: LIVING
-CogMonkey: LIVING
-DawnBreaker_23: LIVING
-SnipySev: LIVING
-gdn001: LIVING
-jarreguin001: LIVING
-butter-kicker: LIVING

I will update the list as more people show up. Even if you are going to be like, inactive here for one reason or another, it would be reassuring to get a confirmation for such a thing as it is still early in the game. (I know it's in the first 24 hours and not all people have seen this yet.)

I'm here. I just didn't have any reason to say anything. except for abstaining and such.

http://i.imgur.com/7LmAU.gif

ARD
01-09-2014, 07:45 PM
Ard is CogMonkey. I think

Balls, I was going to vote for Ali to host the next game because he doesn't know my true identity and since everyone votes for ard and never cogmonkey I would win by default.

But now you've ruined that plan, you mafia scum :cry:

jk Rawk is the only person I could accuse at this point in any mafia game.

Dragonvarsity
01-09-2014, 07:45 PM
... See what you do, Ard? NOW NO ONE REMEMBER YOUR TRUE NAME!

Anyway, not to get back on track or anything, but... can we get back on track?

I remember!

*sees that I'm not welcome here*

FreeAim
01-09-2014, 08:05 PM
Who is Ard anyway? I have read the posts about that person three times over but I still don't have a clue.

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 08:10 PM
Who is Ard anyway? I have read the posts about that person three times over but I still don't have a clue.

Ard is Life.

ARD
01-09-2014, 08:24 PM
I've changed my mind, FreeAim should host the next game.

Ryan86me
01-09-2014, 08:54 PM
Who is Ard anyway? I have read the posts about that person three times over but I still don't have a clue.
Holy crap, this is sad.

Ard is another name for-
*STATIC**STATIC*

Hello? K, signals back. Ard's true identity is-
*STATIC**STATIC*

--End Transmission--

FreeAim
01-09-2014, 09:00 PM
Screw you guys.

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 09:04 PM
Screw you guys.

But especially Ard.

Shooter0898
01-09-2014, 09:14 PM
I thought this site was weird... Glad I'm wrong.

FreeAim
01-09-2014, 09:32 PM
Not here to bully anyone or anything, but...

47508

http://www.lbpcentral.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=47508&d=1389306610

I mean, this could be just a little pop-up by accident or something, but I don't find that likely, especially since if this is his first time here since the game started, he should see that he has new messages in his inbox. I am going to let you guys do your own deduction and I need a little bit more "proof" (if you can call this that) before I am going to vote him out. I would like to hear to reasoning behind this, though, just as a clarification.

(The others on the list have been offline since before I posted that post.)

Shooter0898
01-09-2014, 09:44 PM
Not here to bully anyone or anything, but...

47508

http://www.lbpcentral.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=47508&d=1389306610

I mean, this could be just a little pop-up by accident or something, but I don't find that likely, especially since if this is his first time here since the game started, he should see that he has new messages in his inbox. I am going to let you guys do your own deduction and I need a little bit more "proof" (if you can call this that) before I am going to vote him out. I would like to hear to reasoning behind this, though, just as a clarification.

(The others on the list have been offline since before I posted that post.)

It is a fair point.

RockSauron
01-09-2014, 09:46 PM
It is a fair point.

I dare say it isn't, you peanut imposter.

He very well could be have been busy at that particular moment.

Dragonvarsity
01-10-2014, 01:38 AM
Not here to bully anyone or anything, but...

47508

http://www.lbpcentral.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=47508&d=1389306610

I mean, this could be just a little pop-up by accident or something, but I don't find that likely, especially since if this is his first time here since the game started, he should see that he has new messages in his inbox. I am going to let you guys do your own deduction and I need a little bit more "proof" (if you can call this that) before I am going to vote him out. I would like to hear to reasoning behind this, though, just as a clarification.

(The others on the list have been offline since before I posted that post.)

Heh, funny how he mentions Snipy so many times without actually saying his name. I'm not trying to say this like from a tactics perspective or whatever it may come off as, it's just some weird, grammatical stylistic choice that's now bouncing around in my head.

EDIT: Honestly, not trying to make any accusations. I'm really not sure what logic would come from doing this purposefully in some kind of strategic manner anyway.

DawnBreaker_23
01-10-2014, 03:11 AM
Well most of us already know who "he" is.

FreeAim
01-10-2014, 04:38 AM
What Dawn said above.

SnipySev
01-10-2014, 08:28 AM
Hey folks. Sorry I'm late to the party. I did see the PM, but I've been extremely busy with studying for my exams, so I didn't come here right away. That's also why you probably won't see a lot of me during this game, but I'll try to pop by at least once each round while I am alive.

I'm going to get straight to the point: I think FreeAim's mafia (or "elfo" or whatever the bad guys are called). Since when does absence indicate mafia-ness? If anything, it's exactly the opposite. Getting the chance to be an evil jerk increases interest in the game, not the other way around.

Remember the last time we killed someone based on his Forum activity/thread absence? I do. It was Amoney, during the last game. Was he a mafioso? No.

When I was a mafioso, I was always eager to visit the thread and find ways to manipulate all of you. And I know FreeAim knows that feeling, since he too was pretty darn active when he was one.

So why is he accusing me for reasons that he knows are bullcrap? I think he's testing the waters. I think he's trying to bait you into killing me. If he suceeds, he will have caused the lynching of an experienced civilian right off the bat. It will be easy for him to seem innocent because of how reluctant he seemed to vote on me straight away. If no one goes for it and I survive the day, then he an his buddies can still get me killed at night.

As you can probably guess, my vote goes to FreeAim.

PS: I get the feeling that I won't be lasting very long, so here's my advice to the fellow civvies. Beware those who spend more time talking people into voting than actually casting any votes themselves. Keep an eye on those who spend more time suggesting courses of action than actually taking action themselves.

Ali_Star
01-10-2014, 08:51 AM
Activity has never been a good indicator of mafia-ness. In fact people are more likely to post less if they have a bog standard townie role. And I should mention - just because someone has logged in, they don't HAVE to post in the thread. Why post just for the sake of posting if you have nothing to say? Ok, the first couple of pages might be mindless chitchat, but things are moving on now. SRS BUSINSS

FreeAim
01-10-2014, 09:26 AM
My hunch is currently with SnipySev. This is not because he is suspecting me, but I base this entirely on the evidence at hand, so you can at least see why I think he is scum.


Hey folks. Sorry I'm late to the party. I did see the PM, but I've been extremely busy with studying for my exams, so I didn't come here right away. That's also why you probably won't see a lot of me during this game, but I'll try to pop by at least once each round while I am alive.

I'm going to get straight to the point: I think FreeAim's mafia (or "elfo" or whatever the bad guys are called). Since when does absence indicate mafia-ness? If anything, it's exactly the opposite. Getting the chance to be an evil jerk increases interest in the game, not the other way around.
I was waiting for this.

Now, feel free to disagree, but the case is that in all the mafia games I have played, every time, every single time the players who insist on "not being able to be active" turn out to be mafia/scum. This wasn't only the strategy majority of the mafia used in the "After Darkness", but also in the game I hosted three out of three mafiosi did the very same thing, though one of them was active nonetheless. You ask since when did absence indicate mafia-ness? Not exactly a strong point, since whenever it has been explained, it has indicated so always.

Not once has a civilian/good guy explained that they are unable to be active. Those people are always mafia.


Remember the last time we killed someone based on his Forum activity/thread absence? I do. It was Amoney, during the last game. Was he a mafioso? No.

Amoney was an entirely different case. Amoney had not been into the game at any point, only posting a couple of short statements before if anything, but let's remember that Amoney did not only do that in the game before that (in which he was mafia), but appears to do so in this game too. That is how he plays, no matter if he is scum or civilian.

Besides, I was not claiming you were mafia/bad guy (seriously, this is getting confusing, can we just call them mafia?). I was asking you to explain the reason to randomly pop up, not even making a vanity post here (which you have explained now).



When I was a mafioso, I was always eager to visit the thread and find ways to manipulate all of you. And I know FreeAim knows that feeling, since he too was pretty darn active when he was one.

So why is he accusing me for reasons that he knows are bullcrap? I think he's testing the waters. I think he's trying to bait you into killing me. If he suceeds, he will have caused the lynching of an experienced civilian right off the bat. It will be easy for him to seem innocent because of how reluctant he seemed to vote on me straight away. If no one goes for it and I survive the day, then he an his buddies can still get me killed at night.

I was pretty darn active when I was a civilian too. I was also pretty darn active as the game host. I like being active in this game, no matter which side I happen to fall into and I know you do too. I am not trying to bait anyone, well, I was not trying to before because I had no reason (proof) to (I even mentioned so in the post). Now, however, you have made my opinion change.

I am not trying to kill you because you are experienced, but because based on my previous experience, this is exactly how mafiosi play the game, because it has worked so far. To this, I say: no more.



As you can probably guess, my vote goes to FreeAim.

I hope I have made my point clear. What I do now, I do because I strongly believe it to be the right way to go about this situation, which otherwise seems like it would spiral into chaos for civilians, like every other mafia-game I have been in has. If you do not agree with me, fine, but I do hope you people at least see why I do what I do.

I vote for SnipySev.


PS: I get the feeling that I won't be lasting very long, so here's my advice to the fellow civvies. Beware those who spend more time talking people into voting than actually casting any votes themselves. Keep an eye on those who spend more time suggesting courses of action than actually taking action themselves.

Oddly enough, this is my exact feeling at the moment. Therefore, I speak my mind while I still can:

Don't let anyone manipulate your opinions. If you agree with a point, make sure the point is legitimate, no matter who says it. Treat everyone and everyone's opinions equally, because experience doesn't always mean the person is right. Never join an opinion because the player who says that is highly recognized or even if he has been proven as a civilian. The reason is, that people, no matter how good or how experienced can make mistakes.

PS: Also, I wasn't trying to get anyone attack you previously, but I sure as heck try to convince people to see this situation the same way I do now.

PPS: I think there was a don in this game. I don't think SnipySev is him, though.

PPPS: Now thanks to you guys, I have to take an extra-fast shower. See you soon.

Ali_Star
01-10-2014, 09:54 AM
Is this gonna turn into one of those cases where 2 people are actively gunning for each other, who both turn out to be innocent, while the mafiosos sit there rubbing their hands with glee?

SnipySev
01-10-2014, 10:12 AM
Ali_Star is right. Hey FreeAim, let's make this more interesting, shall we?

How about the others vote either on you or me for this round, and no one else. If the one of us who dies today is revealed to be innocent, then the other one is to be killed in the next round.

If we are both innocent... then we are too foolish to live past the first few rounds anyway.

ARD
01-10-2014, 10:40 AM
Not once has a civilian/good guy explained that they are unable to be active. Those people are always mafia

http://m.quickmeme.com/img/10/1090dc1fdc42e58d45dc1a374db6fbdb2292d5fcaba942aedd ec8558b50a70b6.jpg

No but seriously it's very strange to spend so long accusing someone on the first day just because they haven't posted yet. There is literally zero evidence against Snipy or anyone else at this point so you must realise that your posts will make you look pretty suspicious :cry:

RockSauron
01-10-2014, 11:38 AM
I agree with Snipy. Freeaims arguement is based around a logical fallacy. I know I am locked in a never ending battle with Ard, but that's just for fun. I vote for Freeaim now

Ryan86me
01-10-2014, 12:17 PM
(seriously, this is getting confusing, can we just call them mafia?)
THEY ARE ELFOS!

Anyway, a full report on all of this voting acion comes when I get back from microwaving this pop- erm... once I get home from school.

Dragonvarsity
01-10-2014, 01:18 PM
Well most of us already know who "he" is.

Yes, I know. It just looked odd as a paragraph to me.

DawnBreaker_23
01-10-2014, 03:26 PM
yes, i know. It just looked odd as a paragraph to me.

your face is odd

Shooter0898
01-10-2014, 03:31 PM
Ali_Star is right. Hey FreeAim, let's make this more interesting, shall we?

How about the others vote either on you or me for this round, and no one else. If the one of us who dies today is revealed to be innocent, then the other one is to be killed in the next round.

If we are both innocent... then we are too foolish to live past the first few rounds anyway.

That is an unbelievably stupid idea, not as stupid as voting for yourself nonetheless ;), this will only end badly and give the mafia (still don't know the difference?) a clear victory.

RockSauron
01-10-2014, 03:32 PM
your face is odd

I was going to post this, but I decided I had spammed enough for a day. :/


That is an unbelievably stupid idea, not as stupid as voting for yourself nonetheless ;), this will only end badly and give the mafia (still don't know the difference?) a clear victory.

Let's just call them the mafia and civvies, no point trying to rewire our brains :/

Dragonvarsity
01-10-2014, 05:24 PM
your face is odd

Your mother.


I was going to post this, but I decided I had spammed enough for a day. :/

Yours too.

FreeAim
01-10-2014, 06:57 PM
THEY ARE ELFOS!

Thanks.


Ali_Star is right. Hey FreeAim, let's make this more interesting, shall we?

How about the others vote either on you or me for this round, and no one else. If the one of us who dies today is revealed to be innocent, then the other one is to be killed in the next round.

If we are both innocent... then we are too foolish to live past the first few rounds anyway.
That is absolutely moronic. You know darn well that if we did that, people would vote me out on the first day because people apparently prefer you to me. Then, what would happen the next day? You wouldn't be voted out, you would simply apologize OR accuse me of being the don (if there was one), so people would be all like: "Yeah, Snipy's good!" and eventually, mafia would score another perfect victory. What I find more unbelievably moronic is that you are actually suggesting this rather than trying to bring counter-arguments to my points. For all that has been shown, they still stand. While my vote was formerly with you, it's now confirmed and locked.




No but seriously it's very strange to spend so long accusing someone on the first day just because they haven't posted yet. There is literally zero evidence against Snipy or anyone else at this point so you must realise that your posts will make you look pretty suspicious :cry:
I wasn't accusing anyone of anything before he posted something. I was simply asking if there was any special reason for randomly coming to the forums and not visiting here. While simply saying that it was accidental, for example, would've been enough, Snipy instead attacked me and also confirmed himself as an Elfo as far as I am concerned.


I agree with Snipy. Freeaims arguement is based around a logical fallacy. I know I am locked in a never ending battle with Ard, but that's just for fun. I vote for Freeaim now

Logical fallacy? My deduction is based entirely on facts. Mafiosi have always said that they are going to be busy at the beginning of the game to avoid having to be here. You know darn well it's true, I mean, just look at previous mafia-games if you want! There is no question that Snipy is an Elfo if you just stopped to think rather than instantly bandwagon me because you like Snipy more than me. I am sorry, but it's true. Nothing Snipy has stated against me so far is exactly convincing, you know. If I didn't know better, which I don't, I'd say there is a team-up between you and Snipy (I AM NOT SAYING THERE IS ONE, I AM JUST BRINGING UP THE POSSIBILITY).

butter-kicker
01-10-2014, 07:08 PM
http://annaleawest.files.wordpress.com/2013/05/jfpopcorn.gif

I have no say in this other then as we can recall in the past this normally ends in multiple civvie/elfy deaths. So take a step-back guys and just consider what you could be doing.

Ryan86me
01-10-2014, 07:18 PM
The Reindeer Report:


FreeAim (2): SnipySev, RockSauron
RockSauron (1): CogMonkey
SnipySev (1): FreeAim

The day will end at 5:00 EST today. Well, more like 5:30 - 6:00. I have a doctor's appointment.

RockSauron
01-10-2014, 07:36 PM
So about ninety minutes. Any last minute voters who may want to try and sway the courts?

amoney1999
01-10-2014, 08:16 PM
I abstain.

FreeAim
01-10-2014, 08:19 PM
While I still have the time, I would like to establish that I am deeply disappointed because of every single person who decided not to vote on the first day because "there is no way to be sure."

If you wait until you're sure, the Elfos will be free to take any- and everyone they want or need out of the picture before you even react. Even though I think Snipy and Rock are both Elfos (no need to hide it anymore as I am probably dead), I am not entirely without a doubt, but because the only way this game can be won is by voting for people most likely being Elfos, even though I have doubts, I do it anyway.

This is meant to everyone who abstained from voting today because they didn't want to vote for not being sure.

This is why the scum is impossibly difficult to beat in these games, especially when there are less than 20 people playing. Because when there are at least three bad guys, you are never going to outvote anyone from this game. I want you all good guys who didn't vote for anyone (excluding Snipy and Rawk, if they are Elfys, as they at least voted for someone, though it's the wrong guy) to feel shame and dishonor before the end. I want you all to be taken out one by one with no hope of victory and I want it to be revealed that those you trusted most turn out to be Elfos at the end, so I can smirk at your foolishness and know that there never was a chance, because you're too scared to take action.

As for Elfos, whoever you are, well played.

Well played.

Shooter0898
01-10-2014, 08:33 PM
While I still have the time, I would like to establish that I am deeply disappointed because of every single person who decided not to vote on the first day because "there is no way to be sure."

If you wait until you're sure, the Elfos will be free to take any- and everyone they want or need out of the picture before you even react. Even though I think Snipy and Rock are both Elfos (no need to hide it anymore as I am probably dead), I am not entirely without a doubt, but because the only way this game can be won is by voting for people most likely being Elfos, even though I have doubts, I do it anyway.

This is meant to everyone who abstained from voting today because they didn't want to vote for not being sure.

This is why the scum is impossibly difficult to beat in these games, especially when there are less than 20 people playing. Because when there are at least three bad guys, you are never going to outvote anyone from this game. I want you all good guys who didn't vote for anyone (excluding Snipy and Rawk, if they are Elfys, as they at least voted for someone, though it's the wrong guy) to feel shame and dishonor before the end. I want you all to be taken out one by one with no hope of victory and I want it to be revealed that those you trusted most turn out to be Elfos at the end, so I can smirk at your foolishness and know that there never was a chance, because you're too scared to take action.

As for Elfos, whoever you are, well played.

Well played.

I build my suspicions on day one, I think you made a fair point and suddenly you were bandwagoned quickly which is a bad feeling. I would refer not voting but you seem innocent to me, vote SnipySev. I don't think FreeAim is an Elfo and Snipy did answer with aggression.

DawnBreaker_23
01-10-2014, 09:38 PM
I vote Rock so it can be a 3sum. ;)

RockSauron
01-10-2014, 09:42 PM
I vote Rock so it can be a 3sum. ;)

... You dirty, dirty girl.

Shooter0898
01-10-2014, 09:44 PM
I vote Rock so it can be a 3sum. ;)

The quote archive was made for you.

butter-kicker
01-10-2014, 10:00 PM
So what happens in case of a draw? :confused:

FreeAim
01-10-2014, 10:11 PM
It is especially problematic if two or more are Elfos, since they are allowed to message each other.

I don't really know if anything that won't ruin everything can happen.

Ryan, we need your leadership! Make up something clever that can't be cheated at under any circumstances! If it's RPS, the Elfos can just choose the same ones all the time, so it will never end. This demands something different.

Shooter0898
01-10-2014, 10:13 PM
So what happens in case of a draw? :confused:

Random.org or three-way Rock, Paper, Scissors

Random is the fairest and with no hint on cheating... Probably.

RockSauron
01-10-2014, 10:16 PM
Gentlemen, I just would like to point out that people are trying to kill me off because Ard only joins to kill me off and Dawn wants a "3sum", despite that not making sense in this context. Please, think twice before killing someone off for these rather pointless motives.

Shooter0898
01-10-2014, 10:19 PM
Gentlemen, I just would like to point out that people are trying to kill me off because Ard only joins to kill me off and Dawn wants a "3sum", despite that not making sense in this context. Please, think twice before killing someone off for these rather pointless motives.

I thought Cog was doing it as a joke?

RockSauron
01-10-2014, 10:35 PM
I thought Cog was doing it as a joke?

Ard. Cog is someone completely different.

And exactly! Are you really going to let me die for such nonsensical reasons as these?

Ryan86me
01-10-2014, 11:21 PM
Surprise vote comes from Shooter and Dawn, ending the day in a 3-way tie.

Random.org, here I come.

The night begins.​

Ali_Star
01-10-2014, 11:24 PM
Wots going on? :confused:

jarreguin001
01-11-2014, 08:13 AM
Hey!!! I'm here!!!

Again, sorry for my inactivity. As I told you, very busy with studying.
I see the game has already kicked off... quite rapidly.

FreeAim
01-11-2014, 08:15 AM
Night! Boy have I been anticipating this one.

https://24.media.tumblr.com/66472e6f5993c09dbb29a0c25fa2d90f/tumblr_myy51uUk3u1smba2ao1_250.gif

butter-kicker
01-11-2014, 09:37 AM
http://24.media.tumblr.com/3f819221d6aeb0ec3819f31c06f83c5b/tumblr_mo22plJ4Pr1splcbgo1_500.gif

SnipySev
01-11-2014, 11:11 AM
Okay, so I'm perfectly aware that I am speaking out of turn, since it's night. But as I said, I've been very busy, and I couldn't come visit sooner. So please indulge me on this one.

For the record, what I proposed wasn't a trap. It was a challenge. And to prove that, I am telling you now that if FreeAim dies tonight and is revealed to be a civilian, you can kill me next. And I won't even try to convince you not to. That is a promise.

The fact that FreeAim didn't accept says a lot. Either he's a mafioso scared of getting killed, or he doesn't have that much confidence in his accusation.

But I also challenged FreeAim to see how other people would react. If both of us are civilians, then the mafia would probably take advantage of the opportunity to get us both killed in the first two rounds. That's why RockSauron became one of my top suspects: he voted on FreeAim just after I made the proposal.

That is all.

FreeAim
01-11-2014, 12:00 PM
http://www.head-fi.org/content/type/61/id/519861/width/304/height/182

I think Snipy can have a point here. I really do, and while he has yet to defy anything I blamed him for and his entire "challenge" sort of backfired, I think he may have a point. Then again, there is an equal chance that both, Rock and Snipy are Elfos. I mean, if Rock pulls the short straw, then Snipy suspecting him could be seen as a redeemer and if he draws the short draw, then it would work as a redeemer for Rock. So, until my original points are defied, I still think both SnipySev and RockSauron are Elfos. (Besides, if he suspected Rock earlier, why not change his vote and speak then?)

I am still afraid that you (and in matter of fact, I too) did speak out of turn.

For that, I apologize, but one for one, aye?

flamingemu
01-11-2014, 05:48 PM
Sorry for inactivity, was in hospital +exams an such.

RockSauron
01-11-2014, 05:57 PM
Sorry for inactivity, was in hospital +exams an such.

:O Are you ok?

Oh, and, no clue how I'm supposed to defend myself now. Oh well, I suck at this now I guess

flamingemu
01-11-2014, 06:09 PM
:O Are you ok?

Oh, and, no clue how I'm supposed to defend myself now. Oh well, I suck at this now I guess

Yup, I'm alright. Also how have you managed to already get yourself killed

FreeAim
01-11-2014, 06:43 PM
Yup, I'm alright. Also how have you managed to already get yourself killed
Because Dawnbreaker wanted, by her own words, "a 3sum".

**** am I feeling some proper mafia-game tension over here! There is no way in Finland I am going to wait until 3AM to see the results, so I will probably check them out between 6 and 9 hours since they are revealed.

Shooter0898
01-11-2014, 07:33 PM
Well for the sake of tradition of being spammy during the night...

Is it day yet?

Ryan86me
01-12-2014, 01:47 AM
http://i.imgur.com/h7g8BX2.png

The Deaths:
-CogMonkey (Elfy)
-SnipySev (Elfy)

The day will end at 5:00 EST on January 14, 2014. Good luck.

RockSauron
01-12-2014, 01:55 AM
And today, children, we learned not to accuse people just because they didn't post here right away.

And Ard's dead now. Well, considering the fact he wasn't going to contribute anyway beyond voting for me, might just be for the best in the long term. We need people who vote for more than just some elaborate (or simplistic as it were) joke

DawnBreaker_23
01-12-2014, 02:33 AM
There are 12 players. So I'm going yo assume there are like 3 Elfos. So now it's 7v3 The night ended pretty quickly so I guess it's safe to assume 2 of those Elfos are active. Of course these are all assumptions.

FreeAim
01-12-2014, 08:11 AM
Sorry, SnipySev, but I did genuinely thought that you were an Elfo. However, considering you are revealed as an Elfy sort of makes this thing easier to unravel and it also means that your suspicions about Rock being an Elfo may be true after all. Still, I am not convinced until I investigate the evidence myself, but so far it at least seems legit.

I hate to admit this, but Snipy really was two steps ahead of me here. Once again, I apologize... unless somebody wants to bring up the argument that he was the Don, which I personally don't find likely. He's not subtle enough for that.

To Rock, I would simply say that I never accused him of being an Elfo because he didn't post here. Well, I did, but I had other reasons as well. Besides, it was not as if voting was going to be easy at this point anyway, since anything one could accuse another person of would be so light in comparison to what people can accuse other people of, during day 2.

Now, I too find the fact that there are three Elfos very likely, because four would be too much and considering how hard they are to kill if they are inactive, three wouldn't be too little at all, but two just might, if you accidentally kill one during day one.

Uh-huh. Day two, day two, day two... I think I will be posting mega-posts soon, since Ryan is currently occupied with running the show. Speak to you soon. I think I will go with someone not-so-obvious, out-of-the-box, you might say. Butter-Kicker or Shooter... yeah, I'll make a mega-post about the one I can find more stuff to gnaw on.

jarreguin001
01-12-2014, 08:53 AM
I honestly have a great idea on who to vote for, and have good reasons, but I know it'll just be a dumb choice. It'll make me look like the bad person. And rock is absolutely right.

butter-kicker
01-12-2014, 09:44 AM
Uh-huh. Day two, day two, day two... I think I will be posting mega-posts soon, since Ryan is currently occupied with running the show. Speak to you soon. I think I will go with someone not-so-obvious, out-of-the-box, you might say. Butter-Kicker or Shooter... yeah, I'll make a mega-post about the one I can find more stuff to gnaw on.

It's clever of you to think outside of the box because I can agree that in the past at least one mafia member has been someone you wouldn't expect at all. However I bring you back to my previous statement...



I have no say in this other then as we can recall in the past this normally ends in multiple civvie/elfy deaths. So take a step-back guys and just consider what you could be doing.

At this point I was obviously referring mainly to Freeaim and SnipySev's dispute. So ask yourself this: If indeed both Freeaim and Snipy are civvies then why would I try to intervene if I was an elfo? Wouldn't I step back and watch the carnage. I have nothing to say in terms of shooter though.

Also how come shooter gets a nick but I am still "Butter-kicker" ;)

Shooter0898
01-12-2014, 09:52 AM
Sorry Snipy but I felt FreeAim shouldn't have died for listing one point but what would have happened if FreeAim died and was found innocent? We would have lynched you as per your requests. Meaning that wouldn't have ended well.

Let's play this smart or the Elfo's will win.

SnipySev
01-12-2014, 09:59 AM
Probably better this way. As I said, I am in the middle of exam season and I won't have the time or presence of mind to see this one through.

Shooter, I did tell you my gambit had a secondary purpose. If it turned out FreeAim was innocent, maybe we could have uncovered some mafiosos by judging the way people reacted to the challenge. A mafioso would jump at the chance to get two civvies lynched in a row.

If I sacrificed my life in vain? Maybe, but these games are getting a little samey for me. I wanted to take a big risk for once, instead of doing the safest thing as we always do.

FreeAim
01-12-2014, 11:06 AM
Also how come shooter gets a nick but I am still "Butter-kicker" ;)

Don't worry, I am not currently in the mindset that you are an Elfo, so I don't think I'll make a mega-post about you, yet. I also called you by your entire username, because it's too cool not to use as often as possible.

There are a few, um, plans that I hope to initiate as soon as possible. As for now, you've got a mega-post coming for (probably) Shooter later today (not claiming he's a bad guy at this point, not at all, I am simply going to make a mega-post because there is interesting stuff there to discuss). That or Rock.

Also, Snipy, red text.

EDIT: I find it extremely tedious that Snipy's plan was basically sacrificing me for the sake of uncovering a few Elfos. No, it's not a bad plan, it's a genius one, but way too... gruesome for me, in my opinion.

gdn001
01-12-2014, 11:09 AM
*Mafia-hunter partner killed off on first night*
https://31.media.tumblr.com/f0b6ad4014210e2791e52b36dd239099/tumblr_myl4ywNlfB1rome1po1_r2_400.gif

Although I have yet to start contributing to the thread. Maybe this day I'll do it. :p

ARD
01-12-2014, 01:47 PM
Well that's interesting. If I'd realised Snipy had picked up another vote I would have changed my vote to FreeAim but alas, I appear to have woken up this morning rather dead. I couldn't even escape the mafi-elves or whatever their called by using a false identity. I'm going to stick around though because the reaction to the first night has been very interesting and I want to see how things develop.

/haunt

SnipySev
01-12-2014, 02:31 PM
*Mafia-hunter partner killed off on first night*
https://31.media.tumblr.com/f0b6ad4014210e2791e52b36dd239099/tumblr_myl4ywNlfB1rome1po1_r2_400.gif

Although I have yet to start contributing to the thread. Maybe this day I'll do it. :p

Sorry man. I hope you survive, but I'll save you a spot on the best cloud just in case.

Go get 'em.

Ryan86me
01-12-2014, 04:33 PM
Sorry man. I hope you survive, but I'll save you a spot on the best cloud just in case.

Go get 'em.
Red...

RockSauron
01-12-2014, 04:37 PM
Red...

THE BLOOD OF ANGRY MEN! :kz:

DawnBreaker_23
01-12-2014, 05:03 PM
THE BLOOD OF ANGRY MEN! :kz:

My blood's black, you know?

FreeAim
01-12-2014, 05:18 PM
My blood's black, you know?

For some reason this doesn't come as a shock to me at all.

DawnBreaker_23
01-12-2014, 05:37 PM
For some reason this doesn't come as a shock to me at all.
It's a Soul Eater reference. .-.

RockSauron
01-12-2014, 05:45 PM
It's a Soul Eater reference. .-.

And mine was a Les Mis reference... AND YOU RUINED IT

FreeAim
01-12-2014, 06:45 PM
And mine was a Les Mis reference... AND YOU RUINED IT


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykrB0YbvglA

Okay, okay. Time to get into the reel business. With reel business I mean "dealing with few not important things and crazy schemes now and getting into the real things later".


It is a fair point.

Okay, first of all, I know the irony in claiming suspicions on Shooter, but I would be lying if I said I don't feel a little bish-bash going about. Traces are all very minor, but they all lead to suspicions. First of all, I know myself and Snipy are both innocent and while I do feel bad for claiming him for wrong reasons, I feel like it could actually benefit us in the end.

Originally, RockSauron and Snipy were voting for me and I am voting for Snipy alone. Both, I and Snipy are civilians and we both have at least one civilian voting us, only Rock is also voting on me. Now, for reasons whatever, Shooter joins me in voting against Snipy, someone we know is civilian (or at least I am 99.00% sure is). From my current viewpoint, either, both or neither: Rock and Shooter may be Elfos, but I mostly suspect that at least one of them is.

It would be too suspicious for the Elfos to bandwagon either Snipy or me, both of us having experience in this game. So, how to make it easy? By making sure at least one of us dies. If the situation is a tie between two Elfys and either dies, whoever sided with the dead one gets off the suspicious-hook, while it would then be easy to kill the other one the next day, basing on this fact. It would be a simple strategy getting rid of both, me and Snipy early on in the game, while eliminating other possible nuisances like CogMonkey from the side. Judging on the input of the players, my suspicions are that either GDN (who is threatening to start taking part in the game) or Butter-Kicker (the one who tries to peace things out) will get killed by the Elfos.

Okay, so this is a little far'fetched, I know, but that's not the main thing I am posting now and we can deal with that later, or at least you can, if it becomes necessary. I could do the simple thing and simply state my vote and why I vote him, but let make take you through the mega-post I actually made earlier, but accidentally deleted later.

I am not taking too many quotes now, as it is extremely tedious progress, but the bottom-line is this: Snipy, before his death, said he had grown suspicions for Rock. This was an extremely wise suspicion, but sadly it came a little bit too late for anyone to change votes.

Snipy had laid a trap for Elfos and judging by the post, Rock fell for it.




But I also challenged FreeAim to see how other people would react. If both of us are civilians, then the mafia would probably take advantage of the opportunity to get us both killed in the first two rounds. That's why RockSauron became one of my top suspects: he voted on FreeAim just after I made the proposal.

.

When two innocent people claim each others bad guys, it's a very simple progress to make sure at least one of them dies. The Elfos took the full advantage of it, but unfortunately for them, Snipy saw their plan.

Once again, this is not something completely unheard of. We have seen very similar moments before. This is simple bandwagoning. Very simple, but it is disguised as an extremely complicated plot and is therefore difficult to talk about. The bottom-line is, that from my current point of view, the one person who is extremely suspicious is RockSauron. Yeah, bandwagoning is one thing, but the other is his strangely spiking reaction to him being voted as well. The thing is also that the main person voting on RockSauron (even though it was jokingly done), Ard, was killed. By the Elfos.

This could be a bluff to get us to suspect Rock, but this could also be a double-bluff. I think it is the latter, but that's not the main reason I am doing this. The main reason is that Rock has so far contributed nothing to the game but bandwagoning and since the person he was bandwagoning with finds him suspicious, I find it fair enough to find him suspicious for the same reasons myself, though I was the one being targeted.

I vote for RockSauron at the time. (Feel free to ignore the thing before Rock-discussion, since I just wanted to say it now so it won't slip out of my mind in the future, if it is to become important knowledge. For the record, I have currently no suspicion at all for Shooter (and very little suspicion for anyone but Rock, to tell the truth), so no need to worry about that.)

RockSauron
01-12-2014, 07:00 PM
Welp, looks like you guys are much better at this game than me by now lol. Not saying anything, but I fail at not being suspicious ;-;

jarreguin001
01-12-2014, 07:27 PM
Welp, looks like you guys are much better at this game than me by now lol. Not saying anything, but I fail at not being suspicious ;-;

Hmmm... not sure if this means that you are an Elfo, or you're not...

All I can say is that, inactivity might be an Elfo strategy this time around.
There are just too many things fishy about the inactive people right now.

Ali_Star
01-12-2014, 07:30 PM
Can I just say that the fact that we're using "Elfy" and "Elfo" is incredibly confusing. Can easily get them mixed up. For the record I'm gonna stick to the old nomenclature.

@jarr - there's nothing fishy about the innactive people. I swear to Dog, I wish people would stop trying to draw attention to the innactive players. It happens every game, and every time we vote on that basis, we fail, so lets just concentrate on the people that are active, eh? Since they're the ones who are actually influencing the game. I can't be the only one that thinks that this makes sense, surely?

Shooter0898
01-12-2014, 07:34 PM
Can I just say that the fact that we're using "Elfy" and "Elfo" is incredibly confusing. Can easily get them mixed up. For the record I'm gonna stick to the old nomenclature.

@jarr - there's nothing fishy about the innactive people. I swear to Dog, I wish people would stop trying to draw attention to the innactive players. It happens every game, and every time we vote on that basis, we fail, so lets just concentrate on the people that are active, eh? Since they're the ones who are actually influencing the game. I can't be the only one that thinks that this makes sense, surely?

Agreed

jarreguin001
01-12-2014, 07:39 PM
@jarr - there's nothing fishy about the innactive people. I swear to Dog, I wish people would stop trying to draw attention to the innactive players. It happens every game, and every time we vote on that basis, we fail, so lets just concentrate on the people that are active, eh? Since they're the ones who are actually influencing the game. I can't be the only one that thinks that this makes sense, surely?

Exactly! It happens every game! So now, they're being inactive on purpose in order to fool the Elfies (civillians) in order to survive. Don't hold me guilty of anything, but if I die at night, it means they are using this strategy.

SnipySev
01-12-2014, 09:02 PM
Welp, looks like you guys are much better at this game than me by now lol. Not saying anything, but I fail at not being suspicious ;-;

Well, you do proclaim yourself as an evil lord in your signature. It's not exactly brilliant PR.

Shooter0898
01-12-2014, 09:11 PM
Well, you do proclaim yourself as an evil lord in your signature. It's not exactly brilliant PR.

He's not kidding, soon we will be free of the evil overlord.

*que "do you hear the peanuts sing"

FreeAim
01-12-2014, 09:12 PM
Well, you do proclaim yourself as an evil lord in your signature. It's not exactly brilliant PR.

Can this thing be archived?


Can I just say that the fact that we're using "Elfy" and "Elfo" is incredibly confusing. Can easily get them mixed up. For the record I'm gonna stick to the old nomenclature.

@jarr - there's nothing fishy about the innactive people. I swear to Dog, I wish people would stop trying to draw attention to the innactive players. It happens every game, and every time we vote on that basis, we fail, so lets just concentrate on the people that are active, eh? Since they're the ones who are actually influencing the game. I can't be the only one that thinks that this makes sense, surely?

You haven't really been active yourself, hmm...

Elfy - Good guy.
Elfo - Scum.
This statement - Racist.

Darn them South-Elves to oblivion!

RockSauron
01-12-2014, 09:16 PM
He's not kidding, soon we will be free of the evil overlord.

*que "do you hear the peanuts sing"

You DO realize everyone singing that died, right?

:kz:

Anyway, not to get back on track or anything, but can we get back on track?

Did anyone vote yet?

FreeAim
01-12-2014, 09:21 PM
You DO realize everyone singing that died, right?

:kz:

Anyway, not to get back on track or anything, but can we get back on track?

Did anyone vote yet?
Well...

Awkward...



I vote for RockSauron at the time.

Shooter0898
01-12-2014, 09:22 PM
You DO realize everyone singing that died, right?

:kz:

Anyway, not to get back on track or anything, but can we get back on track?

Did anyone vote yet?

FreeAim i think has voted no other activity.

Ryan86me
01-13-2014, 12:44 AM
The Racist Report (friggen south elves...)

RockSauron (1): FreeAim

The day will end at 5:00 PM EST on January 14th, 2013.

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 01:12 AM
Aw, that report makes me sad ;-;

jarreguin001
01-13-2014, 03:00 AM
I vote for RockSauron, for simply voting me out last time. I promised myself I would do this. Just remembered about my promise.

Ali_Star
01-13-2014, 08:17 AM
Can this thing be archived?



You haven't really been active yourself, hmm...



No, but as I keep saying, if we keep suspecting people on this basis we'll get nowhere.


I vote for RockSauron, for simply voting me out last time. I promised myself I would do this. Just remembered about my promise.

Another rubbish reason for voting for someone.

I'm assuming people don't want to try to think of valid reasons for voting other than revenge, or innactivity?

FreeAim
01-13-2014, 11:48 AM
No, but as I keep saying, if we keep suspecting people on this basis we'll get nowhere.

It was a joke. Chill.

Another rubbish reason for voting for someone.

I'm assuming people don't want to try to think of valid reasons for voting other than revenge, or innactivity?

I, uh... Well, I sort of... like, made an entire post...

Ali_Star
01-13-2014, 12:14 PM
I, uh... Well, I sort of... like, made an entire post...

This is no place for jokes. Mafia Wars is srs bsnss.

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 12:21 PM
Note to self: in future mafia games, don't say anything

Ali_Star
01-13-2014, 12:29 PM
Note to self: in future mafia games, don't say anything

But then you'd be classed as innactive. And people be all like "OMG, why he log on and not post! Suspicious!" and then they vote you out.

DawnBreaker_23
01-13-2014, 12:44 PM
Plot Twist: Ali is elfo and is playing us all for the fools we are.

SnipySev
01-13-2014, 01:02 PM
Actual plot twist: no one is an elfo and the elfys are just killing each other for no reason. Ryan devised this game as a social experiment for his Psychology class.

jarreguin001
01-13-2014, 01:14 PM
Another rubbish reason for voting for someone.

I'm assuming people don't want to try to think of valid reasons for voting other than revenge, or innactivity?

A rubbish reason? I don't see you giving good reasoning to anything at this point! All you're doing is being the 'big' civillian one should be, and just correcting people. Why don't you actually make a move yourself?

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 01:16 PM
Ok, so serious time...

There are 10 of us now. Considering the low number of players and the inherent ratio of mafia to civilians, I think it's safe to assume there are three elfos. Now, it's entirely possible Snipy was the don or spy or whatever (couldn't have been Ard as he was killed by the mafia), meaning he was a elfo who was reported as a elfy. If this is true, then there would be two mafia members to 8 civilians; if not, there are three mafia members to seven civilians. Probably. Anyway, assuming the worst, let's pretend we kill a civilian today and the doctor fails to save the civilian tonight. Then, there would be three mafia members to five civilians. If we repeat this, then there would be three mafia members to three civilians. Hm.

... If there's a serial killer out there, be VERY careful about who you slaughter brutally!

Ali_Star
01-13-2014, 01:32 PM
A rubbish reason? I don't see you giving good reasoning to anything at this point! All you're doing is being the 'big' civillian one should be, and just correcting people. Why don't you actually make a move yourself?

Erm, because I haven't found anything of note to make me suspect anyone. Pardon me for not voting for someone just for the sake of voting for them.

FreeAim
01-13-2014, 02:21 PM
Plot Twist: Ali is elfo and is playing us all for the fools we are.

Ali has apparently come up with SKIAS, the "Sudden Know-It-All Syndrome". It's basically the person suddenly becoming active and basing all their accusations (accusation here being that we shouldn't vote Rock because he might be someone good, in reality) on knowledge they refuse to base on anything that makes any sense.

Don't get me wrong, I completely think that Rock is suspicious to say the least, but at least he has taken part in discussions before this day. Ali's previous posts are basically joking around, claiming that inactive people shouldn't be targeted and of course: "Wots going on?"

Now, when Rock is being targeted, he suddenly uses something he has complained about earlier in his (Rock's) defense when it doesn't even make sense, since Rock hasn't exactly been inactive I can see two possible scenarios for this: it's either a mafioso (Elfo) trying to defend another mafioso (Elfo) or it's a mafioso (Elfo) trying to defend a civilian (Elfy), so he won't seem so suspicious when the civilian (Elfy) dies. See where I am going with this? Oh yes.

Rock can wait for now. Ali_Star has become my main suspect.

I change my original vote from RockSauron to Ali_Star.

butter-kicker
01-13-2014, 02:38 PM
Ali has apparently come up with SKIAS, the "Sudden Know-It-All Syndrome". It's basically the person suddenly becoming active and basing all their accusations (accusation here being that we shouldn't vote Rock because he might be someone good, in reality) on knowledge they refuse to base on anything that makes any sense.

Don't get me wrong, I completely think that Rock is suspicious to say the least, but at least he has taken part in discussions before this day. Ali's previous posts are basically joking around, claiming that inactive people shouldn't be targeted and of course: "Wots going on?"

Now, when Rock is being targeted, he suddenly uses something he has complained about earlier in his (Rock's) defense when it doesn't even make sense, since Rock hasn't exactly been inactive I can see two possible scenarios for this: it's either a mafioso (Elfo) trying to defend another mafioso (Elfo) or it's a mafioso (Elfo) trying to defend a civilian (Elfy), so he won't seem so suspicious when the civilian (Elfy) dies. See where I am going with this? Oh yes.

Rock can wait for now. Ali_Star has become my main suspect.

I change my original vote from RockSauron to Ali_Star.

So you change as soon as someone tells you to? Also you don't accept Snipy's challenge yet you still insisted on him being lynched and didn't say anything other then "sorry" in response to Snipy's innocent death?

I vote for Freeaim.

I may change but I just want to see reasons why not to vote for freeaim.

Ali_Star
01-13-2014, 02:39 PM
In my defence, my "Wots going on" post was a result of logging on after 5 pints of beer and a Mexican chicken burger (with cheese and garlic mayo FYI), so perhaps you can cut me some slack for that one?

Ok, so maybe I haven't pointed any fingers, but I've been coming up with some reason amidst all the mindless accusations and attempts to push suspicion onto those who aren't able to defend themselves. So I have actually been trying to prevent people from voting based on no evidence. If that makes me an Elfioso, then sobeit.

Shooter0898
01-13-2014, 03:10 PM
I vote for RockSauron, for simply voting me out last time. I promised myself I would do this. Just remembered about my promise.

And what if Rock is innocent? You've killed a civilain for what happened in another game.

I'm sorry but that is worse that voting for someone who is inactive.

Not to mention the fact he already had a vote on him and with the lack of reasoning toward your vote puts you at the top of my suspicious list. I'll be watching...

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 06:06 PM
Currently...

the RAWK: jarr
Ali: Freeaim
freeaim: butter-kicker

So another three way tie.

Well, honestly I can't be too sure. However, seeing as how I don't want to die and all, I may want to even the odds so I don't die...

Hm... Even the odds... At the moment, the number of possible deaths is odd... So I need to make it even! :idea:

I vote for Dawn!

FreeAim
01-13-2014, 07:01 PM
So you change as soon as someone tells you to? Also you don't accept Snipy's challenge yet you still insisted on him being lynched and didn't say anything other then "sorry" in response to Snipy's innocent death?

Excuse me, but what exactly do you mean with that: "When someone tells you to?" Nobody has told me to vote Ali_Star, and as far as I am concerned, Dawnbreaker's post was just a joke as itself. I am changing my vote because I genuinely find more suspicious nonsense going about around him (that has yet to be denied) and until this is to be changed, my vote will stay. The reason I didn't accept Snipy's challenge on day one was because, at the time, I thought he was an Elfo. If I was not voting on him, what would it have accomplished anyway? It's not as if us taking our votes back and abstaining would've changed the tie-situation that the day ended in, as Dawn apparently only voted on Rock because she wanted it to be a tie. Nothing would have been accomplished.

(If you are referring to the night-time discussion, however, Snipy brought that point up way too late so I couldn't change my vote, though I would have wanted to. It was a strong enough point for me to vote Rock instead of him. However, it did come a bit too late and there is nothing else to do about it than to make the best of it now.)

Also, what can one say when accidentally voting out a civilian anyway? You are looking at me like I am some sort of a bad guy because... what, exactly? Not drooling over a dead body with a thousand-word poem? Look, I did apologize. I did all there was to be done and I explained my motives for voting him in the first place. What else is there to do, honestly?

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 07:19 PM
Oh, btw, I was mostly joking about voting for Dawn. Just thought it'd be funny to try and make it a four way tie XD

... Oh god, I have a dirty mind ;-;

Shooter0898
01-13-2014, 08:05 PM
For me no-one is as suspicious as Jar therefore I vote for him. My reasons are in my last post.

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 08:08 PM
So...

the RAWK: jarr
Ali: Freeaim
freeaim: butter-kicker
jarr: Shooter

Welp. This isn't complicated :p

FreeAim
01-13-2014, 08:35 PM
Okay, here's the poem for Snipy as an apology for accidentally killing him:



"Snipy, oh Snipy, I am sorry you're dead.
A big gapping hole in my heart you have left.
Snipy, oh Snipy, I'm sad you had to leave,
as I am sure you had something up your sleeve.

When the leaves fall and the land is brown
in my own tears, I am sure I will drown.
I though you were evil, but what did I know?
By my mistake my own plan did blow.

I know all were glad at this game's return
so I'm sad that on the first day you had to die and burn.
I never wanted to shower upon you my hate
and in the guilt of your death your body I'll cremate.

In the honor of your last will I will this game now play,
if Butter doesn't before that my skin flay.
I hope that you'll forgive me, oh frenemy of mine,
since days are growing darker, and I too may soon die."

DawnBreaker_23
01-13-2014, 09:39 PM
Okay, here's the poem for Snipy as an apology for accidentally killing him:



"Snipy, oh Snipy, I am sorry you're dead.
A big gapping hole in my heart you have left.
Snipy, oh Snipy, I'm sad you had to leave,
as I am sure you had something up your sleeve.

When the leaves fall and the land is brown
in my own tears, I am sure I will drown.
I though you were evil, but what did I know?
By my mistake my own plan did blow.

I know all were glad at this game's return
so I'm sad that on the first day you had to die and burn.
I never wanted to shower upon you my hate
and in the guilt of your death your body I'll cremate.

In the honor of your last will I will this game now play,
if Butter doesn't before that my skin flay.
I hope that you'll forgive me, oh frenemy of mine,
since days are growing darker, and I too may soon die."

Kiss kiss kiss kiss kiss kiss kiss kiss!

Shooter0898
01-13-2014, 09:57 PM
I think it safe to say this is the weirdest game of mafia we've ever had.

jarreguin001
01-13-2014, 10:11 PM
Currently...

the RAWK: jarr
...
I vote for Dawn!

You changed your vote twice in one post.

jarreguin001
01-13-2014, 10:13 PM
For me no-one is as suspicious as Jar therefore I vote for him. My reasons are in my last post.

That's almost as bad as my reasoning to vote for Rock.

flamingemu
01-13-2014, 10:33 PM
Can I be pregnant again yet.

Shooter0898
01-13-2014, 10:37 PM
Can I be pregnant again yet.

May god have mercy upon this thread. :p

SnipySev
01-13-2014, 10:42 PM
Okay, here's the poem for Snipy as an apology for accidentally killing him:



"Snipy, oh Snipy, I am sorry you're dead.
A big gapping hole in my heart you have left.
Snipy, oh Snipy, I'm sad you had to leave,
as I am sure you had something up your sleeve.

When the leaves fall and the land is brown
in my own tears, I am sure I will drown.
I though you were evil, but what did I know?
By my mistake my own plan did blow.

I know all were glad at this game's return
so I'm sad that on the first day you had to die and burn.
I never wanted to shower upon you my hate
and in the guilt of your death your body I'll cremate.

In the honor of your last will I will this game now play,
if Butter doesn't before that my skin flay.
I hope that you'll forgive me, oh frenemy of mine,
since days are growing darker, and I too may soon die."

This is grossly unneccessary, but thanks. Nice rhymes.

RockSauron
01-13-2014, 10:47 PM
You changed your vote twice in one post.

no, the ones on the left were who the ones on the right were voting for

jarreguin001
01-14-2014, 12:08 AM
This happens every game. I get killed at day, everyone believes I am a mafioso, and then the news come up. I'm not, and everybody says good luck in the next game. What happens the next game? The same thing! This game is just too repetitive.

Ryan86me
01-14-2014, 01:18 AM
Can I be pregnant again yet.
No.

...

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 06:12 AM
This mafia-game is a train-wreck.

(In a good way.)

@Jar-Jar

What the heck, dude? You've got like one vote on you and you are complaining how everyone always votes you out and how the game is too repetitive. Seriously, the first day ended with a three-way-tie and had surprisingly much action for the first day. On the second day votes are flying in all directions, changing and shaping until on person ultimately votes for you, which causes you to panic.

There are poems, period-drama, pregnancies, God knows what else and this is fundamentally just a mafia-game like it's supposed to be. Nobody is really interested in you at the moment with the exception of the single person who is voting for you. Man up.

Ali_Star
01-14-2014, 08:05 AM
Okay, here's the poem for Snipy as an apology for accidentally killing him:



"Snipy, oh Snipy, I am sorry you're dead.
A big gapping hole in my heart you have left.
Snipy, oh Snipy, I'm sad you had to leave,
as I am sure you had something up your sleeve.

When the leaves fall and the land is brown
in my own tears, I am sure I will drown.
I though you were evil, but what did I know?
By my mistake my own plan did blow.

I know all were glad at this game's return
so I'm sad that on the first day you had to die and burn.
I never wanted to shower upon you my hate
and in the guilt of your death your body I'll cremate.

In the honor of your last will I will this game now play,
if Butter doesn't before that my skin flay.
I hope that you'll forgive me, oh frenemy of mine,
since days are growing darker, and I too may soon die."

The man doth protest too much, me thinks.

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 11:34 AM
The man doth protest too much, me thinks.

Butter asked for it.

SnipySev
01-14-2014, 11:38 AM
Remember that scene in the third Pirates of the Caribbean movie where everyone is pointing guns at each other? That's what's happening here.

Sorry, no gif. Can't be arsed to go look for it.

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 11:41 AM
Remember that scene in the third Pirates of the Caribbean movie where everyone is pointing guns at each other? That's what's happening here.

Sorry, no gif. Can't be arsed to go look for it.

You're kind of lazy for someone with nothing to do for the rest of the game.

SnipySev
01-14-2014, 11:51 AM
You're kind of lazy for someone with nothing to do for the rest of the game.

Sorry. I did try.

It's one of my rules of searching things on the internet: if it doesn't appear among the first 50 results on Google and you can't think of any more keywords, then don't bother.

Ryan86me
01-14-2014, 12:01 PM
Arg, couldn't find the GIF myself. This will have to do.

http://images.dangerousminds.net/uploads/images/PALINANIMATEDvarwwwclientsclient1web2tmpphpiKEfTg. gif

Dragonvarsity
01-14-2014, 02:16 PM
And this too.

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130328162017/onepiece/fr/images/c/cd/Tumblr_mfvdrjKpML1rcrtxgo1_500.gif

butter-kicker
01-14-2014, 02:37 PM
Pirates of the Caribbean?

Ladies...

Gentlemen....

and those of unspecified gender. I give you Reservoir dogs.

http://mgoblog.com/sites/mgoblog.com/files/ncaa-dogs.gif

RockSauron
01-14-2014, 02:52 PM
You fools- the only one who shoots me is me!

http://bloggfiler.no/afgpics.blogg.no/images/795617-9-1273066909091.jpg

Good luck shooting me...

WHEN I'M ALREADY DEAD

Shooter0898
01-14-2014, 02:54 PM
You fools- the only one who shoots me is me!

http://bloggfiler.no/afgpics.blogg.no/images/795617-9-1273066909091.jpg

Good luck shooting me...

WHEN I'M ALREADY DEAD

I think you'll find that I am the only person here who has done such a thing.

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 03:09 PM
While I could do as much as actually find the DVD, make a gif out of it and post it here, it is much more easy to simply use the picture. And since Rock did too, it is acceptable.

http://static1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120520124121/pirates/images/1/1e/P3Standoff.jpg

---

Anyway, if we could get back to the actual game, that'd be lovely. It's as if a bunch of arguments and accusations were left completely without notice. I would also like to continue discussing with Butter: what does one really need to do but to say they're sorry after accidentally murdering a civilian?

...I'm sorry, an Elfy.

Shooter0898
01-14-2014, 03:14 PM
I would also like to continue discussing with Butter: what does one really need to do but to say they're sorry after accidentally murdering a civilian?

...I'm sorry, an Elfy.

There's is nothing else that can be said. I apologized (I think if not sorry Snipy) too and have moved on trying to fing the real Elfo's

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 03:17 PM
There's is nothing else that can be said. I apologized (I think if not sorry Snipy) too and have moved on trying to fing the real Elfo's
This is all too confusing. Butter, could you contribute?

DawnBreaker_23
01-14-2014, 05:02 PM
This is all too confusing. Butter, could you contribute?

I see what you did there. ;)

flamingemu
01-14-2014, 06:44 PM
I see what you did there. ;)

Winking, is that a gang sign to alert the rest of the elfos that this is the one whom you shall murder tonight? hmm? HMM?

RockSauron
01-14-2014, 06:52 PM
So... is anyone gonna break the four way tie, or should I in a desperate attempt to save my own life?

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 07:19 PM
So... is anyone gonna break the four way tie, or should I in a desperate attempt to save my own life?

Make the feeble attempt. I mean desperate! I totally mean desperate.

RockSauron
01-14-2014, 07:26 PM
Make the feeble attempt. I mean desperate! I totally mean desperate.

I don't like your TONE!

K, Imma vote for FreeAim because he sounded all weird and stuff

Shooter0898
01-14-2014, 07:31 PM
I don't like your TONE!

K, Imma vote for FreeAim because he sounded all weird and stuff

Well at least a decision and no need for random.org.

I'm locking in my vote for Jarr tho.

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 07:48 PM
I don't like your TONE!

K, Imma vote for FreeAim because he sounded all weird and stuff

Well, dang it. This is completely unprofessional, stupid in every sensible way and also a loadsome of bad fortune on me, but if not liking one's tone is reason enough to lock a vote on someone, then actually having evidence based on something is enough reason too. (In addition to protecting one's own life.)

I change my vote back to Rock.

RockSauron
01-14-2014, 07:51 PM
Yay! I do good thinking!

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 07:57 PM
Yay! I do good thinking!
Many brain cells, wow.

Shooter0898
01-14-2014, 08:36 PM
So, what do the votes stand at?

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 08:39 PM
Two at me, (Butter and Rock) two at Rock (me and Jar-Jar) and one at Jar-Jar (Shooter0382782992349928882).

RockSauron
01-14-2014, 08:52 PM
So... considering I only voted for freeaim as a joke, I'll rescind my joke vote because I want whoever dies to at least have some logical basis to his death. Even if it's me. :/

flamingemu
01-14-2014, 09:01 PM
I vote FreeAim because reasons

Shooter0898
01-14-2014, 09:04 PM
I vote FreeAim because logical reasons

Fixed ;)

(This is a joke)

FreeAim
01-14-2014, 09:23 PM
I vote FreeAim because reasons Please, share your reasons.

butter-kicker
01-14-2014, 09:28 PM
This escalated quickly....I kinda don't want to vote for Freeaim anymore he gave a fair point and to be honest I just wanted blame fingers and point names but I don't believe Rawk is an elfo and send him to his death.

Ryan86me
01-14-2014, 09:29 PM
FreeAim (2) - Butter, flamingemu
RockSauron (2) - FreeAim, Jarreguin001
Jarreguin001(1) - Shooter0898

That concludes the day with a tie between FreeAim and RockSauron. The night begins. The next day will begin on January 15th, 2014 at 5:30 EST.

RockSauron
01-14-2014, 09:42 PM
Wait, I thought we had another day? Great. :/

Welp. We'll see who iives in the morning...

FreeAim
01-15-2014, 06:50 AM
This escalated quickly....I kinda don't want to vote for Freeaim anymore he gave a fair point and to be honest I just wanted blame fingers and point names but I don't believe Rawk is an elfo and send him to his death.

I will have your name carved into my skin with frostbites you insecure, murdering psychopath.

You better wish that I will die this night for your own sake or I will bust your Butt... -er.

butter-kicker
01-15-2014, 07:07 AM
I will have your name carved into my skin with frostbites you insecure, murdering psychopath.

You better wish that I will die this night for your own sake or I will bust your Butt... -er.


http://pixhost.me/avaxhome/7d/bc/0021bc7d_medium.jpeg

Ali_Star
01-15-2014, 08:36 AM
So is tonights lynch gonna be a toss up between FreeAim and Rawk then? Or is there a minimum vote requirement for someone to be killed? 2 votes each is a bit of a low amount!

Ryan86me
01-15-2014, 12:06 PM
So is tonights lynch gonna be a toss up between FreeAim and Rawk then? Or is there a minimum vote requirement for someone to be killed? 2 votes each is a bit of a low amount!
A lynch it has been, by the gods of Random.org. The death has already been decided >:)

DawnBreaker_23
01-15-2014, 12:29 PM
A lynch it has been, by the gods of Random.org. The death has already been decided >:)
So evil...

FreeAim
01-15-2014, 01:34 PM
If I survive this, Butter, I will make the rest of your life an eternity in the Seventh Circle of Dante's Inferno. If I won't, I will come to haunt you until you die...

Unless you make me a poem. I did one for Snipy, it's the least I deserve.

Ali_Star
01-15-2014, 02:04 PM
I propose a minimum vote requirement for the next game. I'm not happy with someone being voted off after a measly 2 votes. It should be a number that's closer to representing the majority.

butter-kicker
01-15-2014, 02:17 PM
If I survive this, Butter, I will make the rest of your life an eternity in the Seventh Circle of Dante's Inferno. If I won't, I will come to haunt you until you die...

Unless you make me a poem. I did one for Snipy, it's the least I deserve.

Do you want a tribute video?

FreeAim
01-15-2014, 02:57 PM
Do you want a tribute video?
Yes.

But only if I die.

I propose a minimum vote requirement for the next game. I'm not happy with someone being voted off after a measly 2 votes. It should be a number that's closer to representing the majority.

Like 3?

Shooter0898
01-15-2014, 03:05 PM
I propose a minimum vote requirement for the next game. I'm not happy with someone being voted off after a measly 2 votes. It should be a number that's closer to representing the majority.

I agree with this.

Ali_Star
01-15-2014, 03:15 PM
Like 3?

At least 4 with this many players, I'd say.

FreeAim
01-15-2014, 03:32 PM
At least 4 with this many players, I'd say.

At least four votes? That would require at least eight testicles.

http://editorial.designtaxi.com/news-catsinspace1006/7.gif

DawnBreaker_23
01-15-2014, 03:45 PM
Do you want a tribute video?
Twerk for Freeaim. :3

Shooter0898
01-15-2014, 03:56 PM
At least four votes? That would require at least eight testicles.

http://editorial.designtaxi.com/news-catsinspace1006/7.gif

What about Dawn?

And potentially Flame

Ali_Star
01-15-2014, 05:39 PM
At least four votes? That would require at least eight testicles.

http://editorial.designtaxi.com/news-catsinspace1006/7.gif

By this I am to deduce that either:

a) All girls on here have testicles... or
b) Some guys on here have more than two testicles.

Am I correct?

flamingemu
01-15-2014, 07:37 PM
By this I am to deduce that either:

a) All girls on here have testicles... or
b) Some guys on here have more than two testicles.

Am I correct?

Yep; we keep it a secret though c;

RockSauron
01-15-2014, 07:46 PM
Yep; we keep it a secret though c;

For a second, I thought I might finally know the answer, but then realized you could have been responding to either of those two statements. ;-; WHAT ARE YOU?!

Ali_Star
01-15-2014, 07:56 PM
For a second, I thought I might finally know the answer, but then realized you could have been responding to either of those two statements. ;-; WHAT ARE YOU?!

I thought the very same thing!

FreeAim
01-15-2014, 08:15 PM
It's annoying when you're trying to sleep during these mafia-nights, but you can't and you just

https://31.media.tumblr.com/87d41e3a6bf4a8ba8650ea9389a8f256/tumblr_mze81tjAel1sfrfwko1_400.gif

flamingemu
01-15-2014, 08:17 PM
It's annoying when you're trying to sleep during these mafia-nights, but you can't and you just

https://31.media.tumblr.com/87d41e3a6bf4a8ba8650ea9389a8f256/tumblr_mze81tjAel1sfrfwko1_400.gif

Oh my god I remember that show!

Shooter0898
01-15-2014, 08:20 PM
It's annoying when you're trying to sleep during these mafia-nights, but you can't and you just

https://31.media.tumblr.com/87d41e3a6bf4a8ba8650ea9389a8f256/tumblr_mze81tjAel1sfrfwko1_400.gif

Where is the thanks! Button.

Ryan86me
01-15-2014, 10:25 PM
http://i.imgur.com/W0f2F86.jpg

It appears the game is over. The Elfos have 4 living members, and, by the above deaths, the Elfys only have 3. It's been fun. And short. Really, really short.

Elfys:

1 -Shooter0898 Sneaky Elfy
2 -amoney1999 Elfy
3 -FreeAim Elfy
4 -Ali_Star Elfy
5 -CogMonkey Elfy
6 -DawnBreaker_23 Magical Healer Elfy
7 -SnipySev Elfy
8 -jarreguin001 Psychic Elfy


Elfos:


1 -flamingemu Sneaky Elfo
2 -RockSauron The Donny Elfo
3 -gdn001 Elfo
4 -butter-kicker Reporter ElfoWEBSITE: http://us9.chatzy.com/97579334136214
PASSWORD: REDACTEDYou are a sneaky elfy, of North Elf (Elfy) Allegiance. As a sneaky elfy, you have the power to, twice a game, kill whoever you please during the night. Additionally, you also have all of the powers of a standard elfy. Good luck!

You are a standard, run-of-the-mill elfy, of North Elf (Elfy) Allegiance. Possessing no real special powers, you can vote during the day and partcipate in thread conversations. Better luck next time, and good luck!


You are a magical healer elfy, of North Elf (Elfy) Allegiance. Every night, you have the ability to PM to me the name of one single person whom you want to protect. Unless they were voted out during the day (in which case they die), they will have full immunity against all attacks. Additionally, you also have all of the powers of a standard elfy. Good luck!


You are a psychic elfy, of North Elf (Elfy) Allegiance. Every night, you have the ability to PM to me the name of a player who's role you want to detect. Their true role will be, by me, provided, even if they are the donny elfo. However, since there's no way for the other players to be certain of your role as a psychic elfy, you will have to use your persuasive skills to convince the other elfies of your discoveries. Additionally, you also have all of the powers of a standard elfy. There's a new twist, as well. Upon death, you will be reported as a standard elfy. You are not allowed, after death, to state that you are anything other than a standard elfy, and you are not allowed, during the day, to inform the other citizens of everything here in bold (including this, in a sort of paradoxical manner). Good luck!






You are a sneaky elfo, of South Elf (Elfo) Allegiance. As a sneaky elfo, you have the power to, once during the game, kill whoever you please during the night. Additionally, you also have all of the powers of a standard elfo. Good luck!


You are the donny elfo, of South Elf (Elfo) Allegiance. As the donny elfo, you will operate as a standard elfo. However, upon death, you will be reported as an elfy. Good luck!


You are a standard, run-of-the-mill elfo, of South Elf (Elfo) Allegiance. Every night, you will collaborate with the other Southern members to decide what North Elf will be killed in a dedicated chat. Good luck!


You are a reporter elfo, of South Elf (Elfo) Allegiance. Every night, you will collaborate with the other South members to decide what North Elf will be killed in a dedicated chat. Your special power, you ask? Don't get too worked up. Your job is to PM me who the group decides will be killed during the night. If the PM is not recieved by the time I am going to start the day, I will search through the chat to see the decision (your job is just to make my life easier). Good luck!Of course, props go to the Elfos for a flawless victory.
http://static.fjcdn.com/gifs/...Flawless%2Bvictory_6dec72_4686888.gif

Shooter0898
01-15-2014, 10:28 PM
The bad thing is I was originally going to kill Butter.

RockSauron
01-15-2014, 10:32 PM
This was too easy. really, too easy. :/

jarreguin001
01-15-2014, 10:34 PM
Wow! That was an incredible game! Thanks for letting me be a part of it! I love the hidden white messages by the way!

Pretty disappointed.. what a short game...

RockSauron
01-15-2014, 10:35 PM
Also, can't believe random.org favored me twice ;-;

Shooter0898
01-15-2014, 10:40 PM
This was too easy. really, too easy. :/

I had kinda figured you out by being completely wrong with Snipy. I assumed he was the Don and you had protected him since you were voting FreeAim and then again on the second day. I suspected Butter due to him also voting FreeAim on day 2. My plan was originally to bury Butter and then you if you survived. Well that didn't work as I thought hmmm Ali is talking a lot about not suspecting inactives but is not posting and contributing a lot.

Oh well good game.

SnipySev
01-16-2014, 12:10 AM
So... a third of the players were elfos? And one of them had the power to perform an extra assassination? Doesn't that seem a tiny bit incredibly unbalanced?

There's something terribly wrong with your game when the mafia is able to win after just two rounds. Just saying.

RockSauron
01-16-2014, 12:14 AM
So... a third of the players were elfos? And one of them had the power to perform an extra assassination? Doesn't that seem a tiny bit incredibly unbalanced?

There's something terribly wrong with your game when the mafia is able to win after just two rounds. Just saying.

I agree with this sentiment. Very badly managed round.

jarreguin001
01-16-2014, 12:22 AM
"There's something terribly wrong with your game when the mafia is able to win after just two rounds." -Truth

Ryan86me
01-16-2014, 12:56 AM
So... a third of the players were elfos? And one of them had the power to perform an extra assassination? Doesn't that seem a tiny bit incredibly unbalanced?

There's something terribly wrong with your game when the mafia is able to win after just two rounds. Just saying.
Yea yea, I'm aware of this now. Wish we could've got more players in the first place.

FreeAim
01-16-2014, 05:59 AM
I KNEW IT! I FREAKING KNEW ROCK WAS A FREAKING ELFO BUT DID YOU LISTEN? DID YOU?!?!

Had I survived, I would've definitely questioned Butter the next round as well, just so you know. I was on track! I was on the freaking track!

Ali_Star
01-16-2014, 08:12 AM
Yea yea, I'm aware of this now. Wish we could've got more players in the first place.

Yeah, plus a minimum vote requirement is a MUST in the next game.


I KNEW IT! I FREAKING KNEW ROCK WAS A FREAKING ELFO BUT DID YOU LISTEN? DID YOU?!?!
!

Well, you also "knew" I was mafia, and that worked out pretty well for you. :p

FreeAim
01-16-2014, 09:13 AM
Well, you also "knew" I was mafia, and that worked out pretty well for you. :p

Well, complain when I accidentally get you killed.

Dragonvarsity
01-16-2014, 11:46 AM
Wow, over that fast? Well, here's a look back at the length of these five rounds of the "new" LBPC Mafia series. (Not to totally ignore the rounds from years ago)

First Round: 106 pages
Second Round: 53 pages
Third Round: 37 pages
Fourth Round: 36 pages
Fifth Round: 14 pages (at the moment)

So it seems the page count has dropped steadily with each game. Well, fingers crossed for another big round when Ali_Star hosts (once we take a bit of a hiatus though of course :p).

FreeAim
01-16-2014, 12:08 PM
This is why I don't like roles with killing powers. They do add a small factor of unpredictability to the game (which is always welcome), but they can also spoil a bit of the fun. I won't complain about this game, as I would have died anyway, but if I recall correctly, Vigilante killed off two experienced civilians in one of the past games (which was also a perfect victory for the Mafia).

Also, I think the post-count here is admirable, taking in consideration the fact that there were only two days and nights in this game. So it's not that players were not prepared for a longer game or that the players didn't have the inspiration to play, especially since we only had like five constantly active people playing.

PS: We shouldn't probably wait months until the next game. Just sayin'.

Dragonvarsity
01-16-2014, 12:11 PM
This is why I don't like roles with killing powers. They do add a small factor of unpredictability to the game (which is always welcome), but they can also spoil a bit of the fun. I won't complain about this game, as I would have died anyway, but if I recall correctly, Vigilante killed off two experienced civilians in one of the past games (which was also a perfect victory for the Mafia).

Also, I think the post-count here is admirable, taking in consideration the fact that there were only two days and nights in this game. So it's not that players were not prepared for a longer game or that the players didn't have the inspiration to play, especially since we only had like five constantly active people playing.

PS: We shouldn't probably wait months until the next game. Just sayin'.

Yep, good points all around. Many people here were certainly into the new game, it's just that the way things were put together made it end quickly. For another big game like Burn's revival, we'll need some time to cool off, with a more balanced set of powers between both sides, and of course, plenty of excitement from the players.

jarreguin001
01-16-2014, 10:50 PM
This is why I don't like roles with killing powers. They do add a small factor of unpredictability to the game (which is always welcome), but they can also spoil a bit of the fun. I won't complain about this game, as I would have died anyway, but if I recall correctly, Vigilante killed off two experienced civilians in one of the past games (which was also a perfect victory for the Mafia).

I agree with this. Maybe the next game (hosted by Ali_star) should be old school themed, and be really similar to Burnvictim's game, which was the most successful.

Ali_Star
01-17-2014, 09:19 AM
I agree with this. Maybe the next game (hosted by Ali_star)

FYI if there's anyone else who really wants to take control of the next game, I'm happy to step aside.

FreeAim
01-17-2014, 12:21 PM
I agree with this. Maybe the next game (hosted by Ali_star) should be old school themed, and be really similar to Burnvictim's game, which was the most successful.

That "old school" Mafia game had like twice the members this game had. I am not laying judgment onto anyone here, but may it be that you are mistaking the fact that that the game lasted for like 99 pages with quality?

I was not a part of the game and I am not criticizing it at all (why would I?), so you may be right with the game itself being very good, but it may also be the amount of players which made it feel as great. We can't exactly demand more players to join, so we should ask for things that make sense. That's all I am saying.

(And judging by the few idea-exchanged between me and Ali, I am absolutely supporting the idea of him being the next game-host! Just do what you think is the best for the game and it'll be just fine.)

Ali_Star
01-17-2014, 12:52 PM
That "old school" Mafia game had like twice the members this game had. I am not laying judgment onto anyone here, but may it be that you are mistaking the fact that that the game lasted for like 99 pages with quality?

I was not a part of the game and I am not criticizing it at all (why would I?), so you may be right with the game itself being very good, but it may also be the amount of players which made it feel as great. We can't exactly demand more players to join, so we should ask for things that make sense. That's all I am saying.

Indeed. The more the merrier. Still a lot of active posters on here who could get involved. Also, as I've said before it would be great if some of the staff - mods etc could sign up for a game.

I feel this game never really got the chance to get going. As always, at the start of mafia games there's mindless speculation and banter, they only really start to develop after the first couple of rounds, when you can begin to notice behavioural patterns etc.



(And judging by the few idea-exchanged between me and Ali, I am absolutely supporting the idea of him being the next game-host! Just do what you think is the best for the game and it'll be just fine.)

Thanks! I'll try not to let you down! ;)